Last week I got into a little debate over Sloan albums with producer Chris Kelly.  He said their best album, front to back, was One Chord to Another. I think it’s Twice Removed (and still do).  When I brought the discussion up to Criminal Records, they agreed with Chris.  Though he still thinks he won, I believe the debate continues.

Funny enough, just today I talked to a friend who believes in the sophomore curse, that all debut records are superior, as “you have your whole life to write your first record”  (Pish posh I say to that!)

All of the discussion has sparked the idea of a ‘Classic Albums Cage Match’, and we're looking for your suggestions.

When you debate music with your friends, what artists and albums come up?

What records do you think should go head to head? Feists ‘The Reminder’ & ‘Let It Die’?  The Weatherthans Reconstruction Site & Reunion Tour?

Also, when discussing music, who do you go to as an expert?

Post your comments on the blog, tweet @CBCRadio3 or email feedback@cbcradio3.com

posted by Lana Gay on Jan 27, 2010